The Atlanta Wine School Wine Barrels of Chardonnay
Jane's Weekly Wine Reviews including Where to Purchase and What Foods to Pair with!
Complimentary Subscription
Wine review email sent weekly.

* Email
* Full Name
* Zip Code
(*)Required

Archive of Tasting Notes

2005
November 3rd Thanksgiving

November 10th Value Wines

November 17th Chilean Wine

December 1st Dessert Wines

December 8th Gift Wines

December 15th Fizz Fantasy

December 22 Reception Wine

2006
January 5th Cheap Sips!

January 12th Big Chill Reds

January 19th Central Coast

January 26th Asian Fare

February 2nd Wine & Chocolate

February 9th Winter Rose'

February 16th Anything But Chard

February 23rd New in Market

March 2nd Tuscany

March 9th Zinfandel

March 16th Southern Hemisphere

March 23rd Pinot Noir

March 30th Iberian Wines

April 6th Offbeat Reds

April 13th Lowdown on Lodi

April 20th Riesling Round-Up

April 27th South Africa

May 4th White Pinots

May 11th Rhone Wines

May 18th Offbeat Regions

May 25th Offbeat Whites

June 1st Coming Up Rosés

June 8th Summer Dessert Wines

June 15th Chardonnay to Chablis

June 22nd Summer Reds

June 29th Summer Sparklers

July 6th Barbecue Wines

July 13th Around the Pool

July 20th Whites Wines in Summer

July 27th World of Rieslings

August 3rd Wine for Salads

August 10th Taste of Germany

August 17th Washington Wines

August 24th Shiraz, Syrah, Sirah

August 31st Route du Chenin Blanc

September 7th Wine & Cheese

September 14th American Rhones

September 21st Taste of Italy

September 28th Big Bold Red

October 5th Merlot for Miles

October 19th Dry Creek Valley

October 26th Wines with Sushi




 


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

November 2nd, 2006
Georgia Wineries

Click to Receive a Plain Text Version

Many times, people ask me what I think of Georgia wines. Often, their faces are distorted in a look of disapproval, and I know what’s happened: They’ve visited one or two that weren’t particularly good, and used that information to discredit the entire lot of now 30 vineyards and wineries scattered around the state.

Most, of course, are concentrated in north Georgia, where topography, soil and climate combine to make the best conditions the state has for growing Vitis vinifera, the genus and species most of us know as Chardonnay, Viognier, Riesling, Pinot Gris, Pinot Blanc, Cabernet Sauvignon and Franc, Sangiovese, Merlot, Syrah, Malbec, Petit Verdot, Malbec, Petit Sirah and a whole list of less familiar varieties that also belong to this classification. Georgia grows a good chunk of this line-up.

And this vintage--2006--may turn out to be one of the best ever for Georgia's grape growers and vintners. While our corn and soy bean farmers have been struggling in this drought, Georgia's viticulture relished the warm, sunny, dry summer, the perfect circumstance for a fine vintage.

From the biggest, Chateau Élan just north of Atlanta, to newcomers such as Sharp Mountain Vineyards in Jasper which opened December 1, 2005, Georgia has a wide range of wineries. They vinify everything from vinifera to French-American hybrids, such as Seyval Blanc, Vidal Blanc--Three Sisters in Dahlonega does an outstanding job with Vidal Blanc--and Chambourcin--see Creekstone's Dessert Chambourcin--to fruit such as blueberries and peaches. And of course, there are wines from the native Scuppernong/Muscadine, or vitis rotundifolia (round leaf). Years ago, there even was a fellow doing tomato wine down near Forsyth, but the phone number on the badly weathered sign that announced the enterprise never produced me a human voice at the other end of the line, so I conclude this endeavor is, shall we say, concluded. And peach wine in Georgia is nearly as old as the state itself.

Georgia's colonial records show that the Trustees were interested in fostering viticulture in the state, to wean British oenophiles off their taste for French wines. But it didn't work in the colony, as climate and soil were inimical to viticulture. But Georgia produced enough wine from fruit and other grapes up to Prohibition to claim a high spot in the national wine production rankings. General James Longstreet, CSA, in his retirement in Gainesville, GA, planted a vineyard and produced wine from it that he sold at his hotel.

Post-Prohibition, Georgia's winery history is littered with some now-closed operations that succumbed to financial failure, while yet others found the labor just too daunting. Indeed, Alan Wilson, who has some 1,000 Cabernet Sauvignon vines, plus some Chambourcin near Cumming, admits there are days when he thinks about digging up the whole business. But he persists, selling his grapes to Eric Seiferth at Crane Creek Vineyard near Young Harris. Seiferth, a retired Army colonel and West Point alum, was posted to Italy, and spent every free moment in the wine world while there. So did Wilson, a sculptor, who went to Italy to hone his stonecutter's skills, and got roped into the grape-growing business as a way of paying part of his rent. Seiferth also works with Lee and Laura Kay and their partners Chris and Kathy Sterns, who have a couple of acres of Norton (a/k/a Cynthiana), Chardonel (a crossing of Chardonnay and Seyval Blanc), and Chambourcin. The Kays also got bitten by the grape bug on a trip to Italy back in 1999, and planted their vines forthwith. Seiferth, who does a superb Seyval Blanc at Crane Creek, is their sole customer.

Growing the grapes is the major interest for a number of Georgians, including Glen and Beckie Olsen of Beca Farms near Cleveland. The couple has five acres planted to Pinot Grigio and Sauvignon Blanc. Olsen has no illusions about developing a winery, as he doesn't want to have to get into the promotion end of the business. So he sells his Pinot Grigio grapes to Chateau Élan, whose winemaker, Dan Baldwin, produces a Pinot Grigio that sells at the winery for $21.

This vineyard business is a labor of love. No matter how tough the work, folks who love it keep doing it. When Mary and Victor Boutier bought Acoustic Vineyard near Danielsville (formerly Gene Marra's Melon Ranch Vineyard), they actually MOVED their vines from near Summerville in northwest Georgia to Acoustic, then renamed the operation for themselves. With a tasting room still located in Acworth, the couple is in the process of building a facility at Danielsville. Their most successful wine to date is the "Skinny Bitch," a blend of blueberry and Syrah. "People can't get enough of it," says the indefatigable Mary, a native of the other Dublin (Ireland, that is).

Danielsville, where Boutiers grow their grapes, is about the most southern point for vinifera growing in Georgia. However, that didn't stop Thomas DeRosset, Jr., and his father from planting Pinot Noir and Chardonnay in Thomson at the 1810 Bed and Breakfast Inn they purchased just off I-20. It soon became clear that they should have followed the advice they got from David Harris at BlackStock Vineyards (see below), as that didn't work. Now planted to non-vinifera varieties, the winery sources its Merlot and Sangiovese from BlackStock, while making wine from estate-grown Chambourcin, DeChaunac, Vidal Blanc, Blanc du Bois, and Spanish Black (a/k/a Lenoir) from Texas, all much better choices for this region.

Years ago, when Fox Vineyard and Winery in Social Circle, also just off I-20, was attempting to grow Chardonnay and not being successful at it, the punch line was that I-20 was the "Chardonnay line," below which vines succumbed to Pierce's Disease. This ultimately fatal condition is spread by a singularly nasty varmint known as the glassy-winged sharp shooter. Above 1100 feet above sea level, or thereabouts, the condition diminishes its impact as cold weather reduces the insect's population. But hold on: There are some attempts under way by plant pathologists at both the University of Florida and the University of Georgia to inoculate vines against this pest. So we could be writing a whole new chapter on this subject in the coming years.

So what accounts for the sudden burst of wineries south of I-20? Fruit wines, that's what. Plus Muscadine. Before you smirk and dis these native grapes, know that Jenne Burgess, longtime winemaker at Florida's Lakeridge Winery in Clermont, FL, wins rafts of medals with her traditional method sparkling Muscadine. And judging a few years ago at International Eastern Competition in Watkins Glen, NY, I sat on a panel that reviewed several really good dry Muscadine wines, an approach to the grape that I thought ill-advised until I tasted those. Wine made from Muscadine is notorious for being "foxy," or very grapey. And it is. But it also can be surprisingly good with barbecue, for a total Southern experience, and never mind how well a good one can accompany a strong blue-veined cheese.

Not done with all that, Muscadine, which includes the bronze variety known as Scuppernong, may provide more health benefits than vinifera. Mississippi State University discovered more than a decade ago that Muscadine grapes are higher in fiber, zinc, iron, and calcium than most fruits and contain higher amounts of resveratrol and other heart-healthy factors than any other grape. Our own University of Georgia has found in Muscadine grape seeds and skins supremely high levels of ellagic acid, which seems to retard the growth of abnormal cells, and that Muscadine outdoes any tested fruit in amounts of total antioxidants.

So that said, what about Georgia Muscadine wine? With some 1100 acres planted to these non-bunch grapes, Georgia is the nation's largest producer of the variety, and Paulk Vineyards, which produces no wine, clams to be the state's largest producer.

In Bulloch County, Meinhardt Vineyard and Winery, which stakes a claim to being southeast Georgia's first winery, now produces wine from estate-grown Muscadine and operates as its own distributor. But now it has a neighbor in nearby Effingham County, where Butterducks Estate Winery makes a variety of fruit and Muscadine wines, as well as purchases Merlot from BlackStock Vineyards.

At the top end of the state, Georgia Winery has expanded into a bright new facility, and specializes in Muscadine and fruit-based wines. I tasted through the line-up recently, and thought the fruit-based wines were much improved and delightfully fresh tasting. I was impressed enough with the blueberry and the peach-flavored Muscadine to buy one of each.

Swinging south, Chesser Island Winery near Folkston takes its name from the original pioneer family. A descendant, Tracy Chesser, is a Jacksonville, FL, attorney, who has started a winery on the family homestead, which sits on an island in the Okefenokee. Production is focused on fruit wines, especially blueberry, but he makes several as traditional method sparkling wines. The blueberry, he says, tastes like a sparkling Shiraz. Chesser is casting about for some vinifera grapes that might hang tough in that neck of the woods. He's determined to experiment.

And in southwest Georgia, Still Pond Vineyard launched in November 2003--on Thanksgiving Day, to be exact. Muscadine wines are the specialty there.

Meanwhile, the pioneers are doing the best work to date. Below is a sample of some of the better wines to come to my attention in recent months. Plus, this year, I've reviewed two wines from Three Sister's Vineyard, the excellent Vidal Blanc and the barbecue-friendly Fat Boy Red, both nicely done.

Joining them soon is start-up Serenity Cellars, a project of former Floridians Joe and Tina Smith. They are currently building their facility near Cleveland, GA, on the back side of Mt. Yonah, where he figures to plant 1400 vines, mostly Cabernet Franc, this spring. He'll be purchasing some fruit from other Georgia growers until he gets his stock up and running. A music sound engineer, Smith is determined and clear: "We're all about quality," he says, not about being big, and is driven by the Bordeaux model. Are we talking Château Cheval Blanc on the "Hooch? Well, nobody ever figured we'd get this far in the first place, so let's face the future of Georgia wine growing with high expectations.


Jane Garvey

Creekstone Chardonnay 2005
Creekstone Chardonnay 2005

Score: 90 Points

Tasting Notes: Medium-bodied dry white wine; medium pale straw. Somewhat shy aromas that become more enthusiastic as the wine aerates, but remain clean and true to type. Oak and fruit stay in focus—and balanced—to craft a tasty expression of the grape, with enough oak to add depth and yet not so much that the wine won’t go with food. Moderately chilled, about 55-60 degrees, in tulip-shaped white wine glasses or, even better, a round-bowled Burgundy glass. Creekstone is the premium label of Habersham Vineyard & Winery in Helen, GA.

Food Pairings: Good food wine: Potato chips with French onion dip; Apalachicola oysters with lemon; pasta with smoked mozzarella and hefty garlic; classic potato salad; smoked salmon mousse on crisp-fried potato rounds; crab cakes; grilled shrimp or scallops with either Rémoulade or French tartar sauce; lightly sautéed pecan-crusted fresh cod or other mild fish

Price: $19
Wholesaler:
Prestige Wine Wholesale

Persimmon Creek Seyval Blanc 2005 Persimmon Creek Seyval Blanc 2005

Score: 88 Points

Tasting Notes: Medium-bodied slightly off-dry white wine (1.5% residual suagr); very pale straw. Very shy aromas of clean white fruits, with flavors that suggest white stone fruits, touch of honeydew melon. Somewhat exotic, with a clean, fresh finish. Good food companion. Seyval Blanc is a French-American hybrid that once grew extensively in the Loire Valley, but no longer is allowed in France.

Food Pairings: Thai-style lemongrass creamy spicy shrimp salad; spaghetti squash with toasted walnuts, walnut oil and grated hard cheese (Parmesan or Manchego), chilled on greens; grilled shrimp or scallops with slightly spicy Rémoulade; butter-sautéed pecan-crusted fresh cod or similar mild fish; crab cakes; grilled chicken apple sausage; veal scaloppini with lemon and capers

Price: $16
Wholesaler:
Distributed by Winery

Tiger Mountain Petit Manseng 2005
Tiger Mountain Petit Manseng 2005

Score: 88 Points

Tasting Notes: Medium-bodied dry white wine; medium pale straw. Delicate aromas followed by more intense flavors of melon, with a touch of peach. Flavor-filled mid palate. Silky texture. Moderate length. Petit Manseng is a Basque variety that grows also in Uruguay, Languedoc, and now some also in California and Virginia. This may be Tiger Mountain’s best effort yet. Look for the 2006 to be released in March. Owners are expecting to plant more, and that would seem prudent. Serve chilled, about 55 degrees, in tulip-shaped white wine glasses.

Food Pairings: Thai-style lemongrass creamy spicy shrimp salad; classic potato salad; pecan-crusted mild white fish; crab cakes with French tartar sauce (not bad with the Rémoulade); grilled bacon-wrapped scallops with honey-mustard mayonnaise; grilled garlic shrimp

Price: $25
Wholesaler:
Distributed by Winery

BlackStock Viognier 2005
BlackStock Viognier 2005

Score: 88 Points

Tasting Notes: Medium-bodied dry white wine; medium gold. Aromas of quince, peach, apricot, with juicy fruit flavors that back up the aromas. Silky texture; a long finish; exotic spice and a tropical fruit character in the finish. Barrel fermented, but oak doesn’t dominate. Better as a food wine than as a solo sip. Winemaker/owner David Harris has some eight acres of Viognier, perhaps the second largest planting of this variety in the east. Serve moderately chilled, about 55 degrees, in tulip-shaped white wine glasses.

Food Pairings: Exotic flavors: Lightly curried chicken salad; grilled scallops with honey mustard mayonnaise; crawfish salad; chicken salad with mango and sweet red pepper; crab cakes; Cajun deep-fried breast of turkey; crab-meat stuffed roasted Cornish hen

Price: $20
Wholesaler:
Distributed by Winery

Wolf Mountain Instinct 2004

Wolf Mountain Instinct 2004
Lumpkin County

Score: 89 Points

Tasting Notes: Smoky dark fruit aromas, toasty oak, which settles down as the wine aerates; dark fruit flavors, with moderate tannin. Long, quite smooth finish. Tasted three times (at least) before now; wine tends to suffer severe bottle shock when first released and needs about six months to come around. Blend of Syrah, Cabernet Sauvignon, Touriga Nacional and Mourvèdre, all estate grown.

Food Pairings: Garlic-studded braised short ribs; pizza with pepperoni and sausage; grilled sausage; roast chicken; garlic buttermilk mashed potatoes; grilled steak with Béarnaise sauce; grilled lamb steak; dark chocolate-covered simple cookies

Price: $28
Wholesaler:
Empire Distributing

Frogtown Cellars Cabernet Franc 2004

Frogtown Cellars Cabernet Franc 2004
Lumpkin County

Score: 92 Points

Tasting Notes: Medium-bodied dry red wine; medium cherry red color. Aromas of red fruits and spice, with well-integrated red fruit flavors. Aged 18 months in oak, but not oaky. Unfiltered and unfined, but silky texture belies it. Very easy tannins. Balanced, refined, elegant. A total class act. Serve slightly cool, about 65 degrees, in tall tulip-shaped Bordeaux-style glasses.

Food Pairings: Creamy liver pâté; smoked liverwurst (Patak); pasta with garlic and smoked mozzarella; grilled sausage; pizza with pepperoni and sausage; grilled lamb steak or roast leg of lamb; steak with Béarnaise sauce; roast chicken; creamy blue cheeses (such as Cambozola). Guessing it would do well with game, both furred and feathered.

Price: $31
Wholesaler:
Distributed by Winery